I'm a Denon, Marantz, Yamaha, and StormAudio dealer. JRiver is far superior for multichannel levels and mixing (except for the StormAudio processors). If you set the Subwoofer to None, some will mix to L & R and some to L, C, R. The mix levels will also not be correct. You have no control whatsoever. Furthermore, most processors will clip the mix. Right now my StormAudio processor clips any bass managed audio when using the multichannel digital outs (AVB or AES) and the volume level is above -6 dB in the processor.
It's hard to understand exactly what you are saying. I think this particular thing applies to only digital outputs (not inputs) on this particular device. I believe your report. Just saying I don't totally follow.
The "very simple menu options" on a receiver do not work most of the time.
I'm assuming this statement is about unusual configurations like 5.0? Or about really specific instances where a lot of things line up like a really hot LFE channel, really hot L, R, no sub out, *and* the processor/receiver turned up to nearly 0 dB?
Because if you are just saying it doesn't work "most of the time" that seems hard to believe since there are so many receivers installed in so many home theaters around the world, seemingly with no complaints about bass management.
I'm certain you have a valid point to make and I would like to understand it. Perhaps I should start another thread and ask you there.
Brian.