Hi BigMike;
I have been curious about this myself.
I have a very fast system (2.2 MHz P4, 512 MB DDR memory, twin 80GB ATA 133 drives running in RAID 0 array), fast video, etc) but my ripping speeds are also less then what others seem to be getting.
So… I ran a test just now on a whole CD. The results are as follows…
Uncompressed WAV.. Start speed 3.1x, final speed 7.5x
WMA @96 KBs... Start speed 3.1x, Final speed 7.5x.
What gives? I thought that an uncompressed WAV should be blindingly fast, right?
I checked the ripped files just to make sure they really ripped to the two different formats… sure enough there were two of each… huge WAV files & very small WMA files with the same names in the same folder. By the way, I played them both back… could not tell the difference on my 10 speaker system.
So why the slow ripping speeds? Why were both formats ripping at the same speed?
The only things I can think of is that something is limiting the ripping…
1: I built my own system from scratch & did not replace my DVD/CD drive as it was working fine & I was very happy with it (a Creative 5X PC-DVD, 32X CD). However, thanks to Creative, the DVD would not run on Win XP as my drive was one model too old for them to make XP drivers for.
The CD portion of the drive worked ok on Win XP. When I added an ATI All-In-Wonder 7500 video card, I used it as it has built-in DVD support (part hardware, part software),
As the DVD/CD drive originally had an all hardware solution (by way of a PCI plug-in decoder card), I’m thinking that the part hardware, part software solution that ATI is providing may be part of my slow-down problem. Don’t know what part is taking care of the DVD & which is running the CD.
2: Another possibility may be that I am no longer using Creative drivers optimized (as there are none available from Creative for XP) for my drive, but am using Win XP default drivers or the ATI drivers (if any).
Either way BigMike, you need to make sure you have the latest (& correct) drivers for your CD drive.
3: There is this possibility… that is, that music CD’s may not rip as fast as the CD drive is designed to run due to the complexity of the music file, or due to the complexity of the ripping process. Remember, the drive is reading & the CPU is writing (through MJ).
3: Another possibility is that MJ is doing a more through job of ripping then other players do (that may be why it sounds so good) & simply takes a little longer.
Anyway, after it’s all said & done, MJ will still be my player for as long time to come.
HAVE FUN!!!