INTERACT FORUM
More => Old Versions => Media Jukebox => Topic started by: jgourd on October 20, 2002, 10:33:25 am
-
In the tag editor there is a field called "Album Artist". What is this used for? Is this where I would put "Various Artists" for a compilation album if I wanted the actual artist to appear in the "Artist" field?
-
It seems "album artist" concept doesn't exist anymore in MJ9.
-
Hello,
Yes this is where you'd put "various folks" for an album with different artists but I think it goes a bit beyond that.
For example in my library I have the famous 2 cd set of the concert "tribute to Bob Dylan" by various artists and the "Zim" himself. What I put in the album artist field is simply "Bob Dylan" so that this tribute album appears under 'Bob Dylan' in the artist/album view scheme. Because for a tribute album I prefer to find it under the artist name than under the anonymous 'Various artist' and I also like to have each track artist with the name of the actual performer. Like album='Tribute to Bob' artist='George Harrison' Album Artist='Bob Dylan'..
In fact the Artist/Album view scheme is in reality an 'album artist'/artist view.
I'm quite happy with this field and if it happens to dissapear in MJ9 I hope it is replaced by another mechanism for 'various folks' albums.
have a nice day.
-
I'm quite happy with this field and if it happens to dissapear in MJ9 I hope it is replaced by another mechanism for 'various folks' albums.
I understand it disappears as a "standard field" (are there "standard" fields though ?) but you are free to add it as a custom field.
Am I right ?
Of course, MJ9 has to be able to import (or convert) this field from MJ8, as for custom_i fields.
Possible bug: MJ9 doesn't see my custom1, 2, 3 fields when I import my audio tracks even if I try to create custom fields with these names.
-
Hi michel,
fait t-il beau à Grenoble ? ;)
-
Ce we oui, aujourd'hui non !
-
Is there a seperate interact area for those that don't want to speak English?
jgourd,
The Album Artist field is for just that... The Album's Artist. If a compilation disk, then Album Artist would be Various. I go a little further and label it "Various Artist" for compilation discs, " Movie Soundtrack" for Sound tracks, and "Tributes" for Tribute albums.
-
Sorry Chico,
Just found a hometown buddy on the interact and wanted to say hello in our hometown dialect !
(was just asking how was the weather like) :)
thank you michel.
-
I understand it disappears as a "standard field" (are there "standard" fields though ?) but you are free to add it as a custom field
The problem is, MJ8 handles Album Artist quite cleverly. In a view scheme, you can set the first field to be Album Artist. If there is an Album Artist, MJ will use this, otherwise it will use the Artist. That means the top level will show all your artists who have whole albums, and "various", "soundtrack", "Cafe del Mar" etc. for compilation albums.
Is there a way to get this behaviour in MJ9?
-
The Album Artist field has been replaced in MJ9 with the Auto Artist field which should be able to work out automatically whether the album is a compilation and whether or not it is complete. Problem is I dont think you can now change it to say movie soundtrack or TV themes or whatever. I will check tonight when I get home and post my findings...
Adam
-
I certainly hope Album Artist is not going away in MJ9, as there are many albums by dj's and mixers, such as Sasha, John Digweed, ATB, BT, Dave Seaman, Nick Warren and many many more. In fact I noticed recently after ripping many of their albums the Artist field has the true original Artist and so the dj/mixer name is getting lost so am having to add it manually in the Album Artist field.