INTERACT FORUM

More => Old Versions => Media Center 17 => Topic started by: greg.smalter on April 08, 2012, 09:33:29 am

Title: Channel changing improvements
Post by: greg.smalter on April 08, 2012, 09:33:29 am
I want to say I'm very happy that you are focusing on improving the channel changing. You definitely solved the problem with MC getting bogged down by rapid channel changes.

There is a remaining issue that occurs with a single channel change. In short, it's still way slower than WMC, but here are two specific things that might help, and these occur with all combinations of DirectSound/WASAPI/ROHQ/ROStd/VideoClock on two different machines so I don't think it has anything to do with audio/video settings:

1. When the channel is changed, all video halts and audio goes away, as expected, but after a second or so, both video and audio from the channel I am changing from resume momentarily (for as many as 2 seconds - this seems like a waste of resources, and it is distracting) before it jumps over to the new channel.

2. When switching to a channel that has a different aspect ratio, the new channel will sometimes play for several seconds (sometimes as many as 10 seconds, but usually less) in the wrong aspect ratio before correcting itself.

Oh, and one little thing - wrapping doesn't work. So if I'm on channel 51.3, my highest channel, and hit channel up, it doesn't do anything. I'd like to end up on channel 8.1.
Title: Re: Channel changing improvements
Post by: rpalmer68 on April 08, 2012, 11:17:44 am
I've noticed these too, especially the first one which does seem rather odd behaviour and must be slowing the change down.

Hopefully Yaobing can get rid of this.

R
Title: Re: Channel changing improvements
Post by: NickF on April 08, 2012, 01:21:31 pm
There is also an issue with changing channel from an SD channel to an HD one.  On change, the video freezes on a frame from the SD channel.  The first time this happens, the OSD shows "Playback error.  Code 8004022A.  Restarting Player.  If I change back to the SD channel, it plays OK.  On subsequent occurrences, the OSD shows the channel I am changing to - the HD one - but no video or audio is played.  I guess there is an issue with changing graphs here.  My memory may be playing tricks but I think we have raised this before.

Nick.
Title: Re: Channel changing improvements
Post by: Matt on April 08, 2012, 07:45:53 pm
If you're not using it, please try Red October Standard.  Does that make a difference?
Title: Re: Channel changing improvements
Post by: Yaobing on April 08, 2012, 09:36:35 pm

1. When the channel is changed, all video halts and audio goes away, as expected, but after a second or so, both video and audio from the channel I am changing from resume momentarily (for as many as 2 seconds - this seems like a waste of resources, and it is distracting) before it jumps over to the new channel.

2. When switching to a channel that has a different aspect ratio, the new channel will sometimes play for several seconds (sometimes as many as 10 seconds, but usually less) in the wrong aspect ratio before correcting itself.

These are known issues.  I will fix them.  1. is harder to fix.  2. is easier.