INTERACT FORUM

More => Old Versions => JRiver Media Center 19 for Windows => Topic started by: MikeDuke on December 23, 2013, 03:40:04 pm

Title: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 23, 2013, 03:40:04 pm
Hello.  I am new to this forum.  I have Baetis server running MC18.  My Red October OS is in standard mode.  I am using MakeMKV to rip my movies.  The issue I am having is that when I play a rip back for a movie that was a standard DVD, the video does not look right.  It's kind of hard to explain but the best way to describe it is that it looks choppy.  This is when I play it back right through JRiver.  But, as a test, I downloaded the VLC playback container.  When I watch a regular DVD that I burned through that player, it looks smooth as can be.  So there are settings that I don't have setup right.  I was really hoping that someone here could help me out in things I could try because I have tried a lot of things and so far nothing has worked.  I think it's under "tools" and "options" I have hardware accelerator checked and video clock checked.  Unchecking them really doesn't make much of a difference so I am really and the end of my rope.  Any other ideas would be very helpful.
Thanks
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: mojave on December 23, 2013, 04:07:31 pm
Welcome to Interact! I post as Desertdome at AVS, but Mojave elsewhere.

I also rip DVD's with MakeMKV. MC18 had a problem for me with some DVD's that was fixed by an update. First, are you using 18.0.212, which is the last version released? You can check your version by clicking Help > About Media Center. If you aren't using that version, you can update from the link in this thread:

http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=82548.0 (http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=82548.0)

If you are using the latest version, then I suggest you try the free 30-day demo of MC19 and see if it plays fine in MC19. MC19 will automatically copy over all your settings from MC18 so it works the same way. The only thing you might need to configure is Options > Audio > Audio Device since that setting has changed. Your MC18 will stay the same and you can still use it. I'm just trying to see if the updated codecs used by MC19 help your issue.

Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 23, 2013, 04:31:33 pm
Thanks for the reply mojave.  I am probably not using the latest version since I have had my server for a few months and never updated anything.  If I do that latest update, will I need to re config anything since it still is version 18?  I will check to see if I am running that version and if I am not, then I will update so I have the latest version.  Hopefully that will do the trick.  I am just nervous about doing an upgrade upgrade to MC19.  Thanks again.   
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: mojave on December 23, 2013, 05:18:18 pm
No, you do not need to reconfigure anything when doing the MC18 upgrade. Just download the file and run it.

Installing MC19 is an upgrade in the sense that your settings from MC18 are transfered. However, it isn't an upgrade of MC18 in the sense that you can still use MC18 just like before. It isn't like upgrading an operating system or anything.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 23, 2013, 06:34:05 pm
OK.  I thanks again.  I may have time to download the newer MC18 tomorrow.  Hopefully that does the trick.  If not, then I will see if I can do MC19 but I am hoping that MC18 is the answer.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 24, 2013, 10:22:46 am
So I checked my version of MC18 and it was the latest version.  Then I went here
http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=86190.0
And clicked the link.  The I just followed the instructions.  It went so fast and smooth that I wasn't sure I did it right.  But, it took me right away.  I checked and it was the latest version.  So I watched a bit of a regular DVD rip.  It looked better but not as good as it did with vlc.  BTW, I did bot have to go into Options>audio>audio devices.  Everything played as it should.  Now, do I have to pay for this upgrade at some point?  I mean the download did not even say anything about an upgrade price.  But now that I have done the upgrade, and it is still not as good as VLC, any more thoughts.  Someone on AVS thought that my video card was not goo enough in my Baetis HT.  But, if regular DVD's look great through VLC, doesn't that mean that the video card is good enough?
Thanks
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 24, 2013, 10:29:22 am
OK, when I clicked on MC19 again I got a window that does say that it is a 30 day trial.  It does say purchase, restore licensee and continue.  I guess I want to purchase?  That would allow me to go from 18 to 19 right?  Sorry if these are basic questions.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 24, 2013, 10:43:57 am
OK.  I really hate to post so many times in my own thread but now I no longer get that little pop up.  It takes me right into JRiver.  When I escape out and go into the normal view, I am in the section where it says JRiver media center and it says Home, download, purchase, etc...  Do I just hit purchase?  It says to go to the help menu.  When I do that I see Buy Media center and Install license.  Which one do I do?  
I will say though video still looks choppy with MC19
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: mojave on December 24, 2013, 10:51:35 am
Just click continue for now. You want to try it for 30 days. I think the message only pops up the first time you run MC19 with each reboot.


In MC19 under Tools > Options > Video > General Video Settings
1.  Are you using Red October Standard or Red October HQ?
2.  Is Hardware Accelerate turned on?
3.  Is VideoClock checked?

What video card are you using or can I get that info from the Baetis website?
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 24, 2013, 11:08:30 am
I am running standard. 
Hardware acc is on and so is video clock
I hope I am looking in the right place but I think my video card is Intel(R) HD Graphics.  I got that by going to the device manager.  If there is another way to check for it, please let me know.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: mojave on December 24, 2013, 11:21:10 am
Your thread is in no-man's land. Somehow it was posted under Older Versions and isn't even under JRiver Media Center 18 for Windows. Unless someone is only looking at new posts, they probably won't see it. I say this since I will only be checking the forum for about another 1 1/2 hours.

With the holidays, not as many users will be checking the forum. However, you may consider posting in the MC19 thread (http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?board=32.0) for more traffic.

I would try turning Hardware Accelerate off.

Are you using any DSP in DSP Studio? The only thing I can think of that would cause a problem there is Convolution.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 24, 2013, 11:29:53 am
I am new to the forum and I thought this was the place to put it since it is an older version.  If I messed that up, sorry.  I will try and turn that off. 
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: mojave on December 27, 2013, 04:25:17 pm
Any success?
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on December 27, 2013, 05:26:31 pm
Nope. They still look poor.  I am ripping another one but I don't what else I can do.  I have one more that I am doing.  I don't want to get to far into an iteraction I had with some one, but there may be a different way to connect the server to my TV so they look better.  But I will need help for that.  Thanks again for your help.  
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on January 01, 2014, 04:54:41 pm
DVD playback can suffer greatly by bad video drivers or bad driver configuration.

I recommend:
- Update Graphics Drivers to the latest version directly from the manufacturer, not through Windows Update (ie. from intel.com)
- Check the Graphics Driver control panel for any Video options, and disable any "Image Enhancements" or Image Processing options, as they tend to harm much more then they help.

For Intel cards it depends on which generation of the driver you're using, but my Intel Driver has options under "Video" for "Image Enhancement", "Color Enhancement", "Image Scaling" and "Gamut Mapping"
All of those should be turned OFF or set to "Application Controlled"

PS:
I also moved your thread into the proper board to ensure it'll be found again.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Zhillsguy on January 02, 2014, 08:28:10 am
If you are running Windows 7 make sure an Aero Desktop Theme is enabled. This caused me problems for a while.

In ROS, try different combinations of all options both on and off.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: CountryBumkin on January 03, 2014, 02:01:29 pm
If you have a powerful enough computer you will want to use RO+HQ. That will allow use of madVR. Then you need to go into madVR settings and adjust to "force film" mode (or "if in doubt select Film mode" or some wording like that.)

Find a post from member "6233638" he has a link in his signature line to " how to setup MadVR".
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: fitbrit on January 03, 2014, 09:05:16 pm
Hi Mike.

I was wondering why you hadn't posted here, but I saw above that you had, only in the wrong forum. I also read the other day that DVD playback can be choppy if convolution is on. I don't really know what convolution is, but if you do, and you enabled it, perhaps that might be a clue?
Title: Re:
Post by: raym on January 04, 2014, 04:42:20 am
I can confirm something isn't right with DVD playback. It is very choppy. The workaround for me was to enable the MS Video Decoder for ifo/DVD file types. This immediately fixes it. Maybe it has something to do with PAL discs? Lav filters work fine for all other content though...
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on January 04, 2014, 05:07:57 am
For everyone else in the past it was resolved by simply ensuring your graphics driver isn't doing bad stuff, so check that. :)
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 09, 2014, 09:16:05 am
Thanks for the replies guys. 
I tried a few things.  When I changed it to the HQ mode, it looked even worse.
Zhilsguy
"If you are running Windows 7 make sure an Aero Desktop Theme is enabled"
I am not sure how to do that

raym (This looks the most promising)
"The workaround for me was to enable the MS Video Decoder for ifo/DVD file types"
I am not sure how to do that.
 
Fitbrit
"I also read the other day that DVD playback can be choppy if convolution is on"
I am not sure how to change this either. 

I tried to turn off
-Hardware accelerator
-Video clock
The difference was not that great.  Right now I can probably live with it.  Unless I can try some new things, I may just have to live with it and see if a "stronger" server down the road will fix the issue.  But I do want to thank everyone for their help and if there are other ideas out there, please let me know  :).
BTW, I am using windows 7.  And I freely admit ignorance to many things so I am not sure how to check if my graphics driver is doing bad stuff
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Zhillsguy on January 09, 2014, 10:38:19 pm
Zhilsguy
"If you are running Windows 7 make sure an Aero Desktop Theme is enabled"
I am not sure how to do that

More than likely you are since it is default....

An easy way to check, while playing a video, move your mouse pointer over the active program button on the task bar, if you see motion video in the thumbnail it is enabled.

If you need to change it just right click in a blank area on your desktop, choose "Personalize", and select an Aero theme (Windows 7, Architecture, Characters, etc.). Once chosen you can further customize that theme to be a solid color, other background, or whatever.

Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 10, 2014, 11:56:07 am
Thanks.  I will check that out just to make sure.  I hope someone can explain the MS Video Decoder fix because that sounds like it could be the one.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on January 10, 2014, 12:39:56 pm
Like briefly mentioned before,  most of the time this is caused by bad configuration in the video driver control panel.

For an Intel GPU, these steps should get you there.

1) Find "Intel HD Graphics Control Panel" in the Start Menu and run it
2) Open the "Video" section

Now the next steps depend on the version, since Intel created a completely new control panel recently.
Assuming the newest version.

3) First Screen should show options for "Standard Color Correction" and "Input Range", and an "Advanced" Tab
Make sure all settings here are set to "Application Settings", and under "Advanced", Total Color Correction should be "Off"

4) On the top it says "Video" with a small arrow next to it, click it and select "Image Enhancement"
5) Like on the previous screen, everything should be "Off" or "Application Settings", both on the Basic and Advanced Tab

6) Repeat the same process for the "Image Scaling" and "Gamut Mapping" options from the top "Video" menu
All options on these screens should also either be "Off" or "Application Settings".

I hope this helps. In older driver versions the options look quite different.
If you don't even have a "Intel HD Graphics Control Panel", I would recommend to start with updating the driver, directly from Intel.com

I have personally tried various DVDs, and everything seems to play just perfectly.
Regarding Convolution, its in the Audio DSP Settings in MC19. If you've never turned it on, then it shouldn't be a problem.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 10, 2014, 01:44:30 pm
Thanks for the detailed instructions.  So that "Intel HD Graphics Control Panel" is something I should see when I just click the start menu?  When you say update the driver, do you mean my video driver?  I am running Windows 7 at work as well.  If I go to Device Manager I can see Display adapters.  If I click on it is names it for me.  If I right click it says I can update the software.  If that is right, and I do update the software, would I then see that "Intel HD Graphics Control Panel" in my start menu? 
I will try my best  :).
Thanks for your help
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on January 10, 2014, 02:24:43 pm
In the Start Menu its probably under All Programs -> Intel.
Without knowing which kind of CPU or graphics chip you have specifically, I sadly cannot link you to a driver update directly, or I would've done that.

In the device manager, does it only say "Intel HD Graphics", without a number behind it?
Do you possible know which kind of CPU you have? The Device Manager may be able to tell you, in the "Processors" category - that will tell us which graphics chip it has, and I could get you a link to the correct driver.

You'll need to download the update software from Intel directly. Windows cannot automatically get the correct update, the one Windows installs automatically is sadly quite a bit limited.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 10, 2014, 02:34:14 pm
Thanks.  I will check that out tonight.  Also, if I can I will get you more info on my machine.  I will list the cpu and graphics card if I can.  I am at work now so I will need to check this stuff out on my machine at home.  Hopefully I won't have to download anything. 
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: glynor on January 10, 2014, 02:46:22 pm
Yeah, the drivers you get by doing the built-in "check for updates" in the Device Manager are effectively useless.  Bare minimum functionality, in most cases.

If that's all you have, you almost certainly need a driver update from Intel.

They have a driver checker thingy (https://downloadcenter.intel.com/default.aspx), though I've had trouble with it in the past.

The main issue is that Intel has discontinued driver support for their first-gen Intel HD Graphics chips, and you need a (still working) but older version for those.  Basically all the newer ones than the first gen ones can use the current GPU driver.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 10, 2014, 02:59:44 pm
OK This is what I am going to do.  I will get the CPU processor, type and speed.
Plus I will get the video card info
Plus I will report what it says in the processor section
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 10, 2014, 07:14:13 pm
OK Here is some more info
Processor Intel core 3-2120TCPU@2.60Ghz 2.60Ghz
8.00 GB RAM
Intel HD Graphics
under Processors
Intel core 3-2120TCPU@2.60Ghz 2.60Ghz listed 4 times

As far as the Intel thing, I did not have anything in my start menu, but if I go to Control Panel I see something called Intel Graphics and media.  If I click on that another screen comes up  I can do a Basic Mode, Advanced Mode, or Wizard Mode.  
If I click Basic Mode I get Sections labeled Display, 3D, Media, and Options and support.
Under the Display section It is as follows:
Display-Digital Television DHC-80.3
Resolution -1920x1080
Color Depth 32 bit
Refresh rate 59p HZ
Rotation Rotate to normal
Scaling Maintain Display settings
The other options really don't apply to me.
Advanced mode adds options that I really don't think affect me.  Now out of all of that, I wonder if that refresh rate of 59p Hz is the issue. It also has the following options:
23p Hz
24p Hz
59p Hz(which is where it is now)
59i Hz
60p Hz
60i Hz
I bet you it's one of the others.  


The specs on my TV(Panasonic TC-P42G25)  say it has a refresh rate of 600Hz.  It also says it can do 24p playback. I guess maybe I have to play around with those?  All I know is that when I put my Integra in 1080p/24 it looks really bad.  Maybe I just need to play with those options.  Anybody have any thoughts based on my specs and where everything is set?
Thanks again to everyone trying to help me out.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on January 11, 2014, 03:13:48 am
That CPU should have a Intel HD Graphics 2000.

Here is an up to date driver:

For Windows 7 32-bit: https://downloadcenter.intel.com/Detail_Desc.aspx?agr=Y&ProdId=3319&DwnldID=23376
For Windows 7 64-bit: https://downloadcenter.intel.com/Detail_Desc.aspx?agr=Y&ProdId=3319&DwnldID=23377

Which of those two you need depends which version of Windows 7 you have, 32-bit or 64-bit.
Once you have the new driver installed, you should get the new Intel Graphics control panel.

Please update the driver, and then try to follow the step by step guide to disable the video processing in my previous post.
Sadly Intel enables this stuff by default, and it hurts image quality badly.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 11, 2014, 02:02:39 pm
Thanks.  So my system says
64 bit operating system.
So if I click on that link I should just be able to update the driver easily right?  I mean, I don't have to un-install anything do I?

Then after that I should follow these instructions right?
In the Start Menu its probably under All Programs -> Intel.
Without knowing which kind of CPU or graphics chip you have specifically, I sadly cannot link you to a driver update directly, or I would've done that.

In the device manager, does it only say "Intel HD Graphics", without a number behind it?
Do you possible know which kind of CPU you have? The Device Manager may be able to tell you, in the "Processors" category - that will tell us which graphics chip it has, and I could get you a link to the correct driver.

You'll need to download the update software from Intel directly. Windows cannot automatically get the correct update, the one Windows installs automatically is sadly quite a bit limited.

I am only being overly careful because I don't want to screw anything up.  I really have not updated drivers on a regular basis befoire.
Thanks
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on January 11, 2014, 02:17:47 pm
Just download the file from the 64-bit link and install it.
It'll ask to reboot, let it do that and afterwards check if you have the intel control panel then.

The instructions are here:
http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=86201.msg592039#msg592039

Most of the settings will already be in the "Off" or "Application Settings" state, but not all.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 11, 2014, 02:56:58 pm
OK.  I followed your instructions on what and how to download the driver.  I followed the instructions for the install and my machine re-booted.  But in my start menu I still have nothing that says Intel, and the layout when I go to it from the control panel looks exactly the same as I mentioned before.  In the device manager section it says that the driver for my video card is up to date.  I don't know what to do now.  Maybe I should just try different settings in that Refresh Rate section because I am all out of ideas now.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on January 11, 2014, 03:18:14 pm
Even the old control panel should have a "Video" section somewhere, or possibly called "Media"

Does it look like this? (this is a older version of the panel)
(http://en.community.dell.com/cfs-file.ashx/__key/communityserver-discussions-components-files/3529/2251.mediacolorenhancements1.jpg)

If yes, check under the "Media" option. It should have a few sub-options, make sure all are either "Off", "Override application settings" is OFF, so that it doesn't override any settings that MC would do.
In the screnshot above, in color enhancement "Override application settings" needs to be unchecked, and similar options for "Image Enhancement" and "Image Scaling" also need to be off.

I hope you find it!
And I hope it helps, not sure what else would influence DVD playback like this.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 11, 2014, 04:06:18 pm
OK.  I don't have the options that you mention,  For one thing, in the media section, I don't have anything that says "Orverride Application Settinga"  I have the section bellow that says standard color correction and lists the Brightness etc... stuff.  Then below that box I have another box that says "Total Color Correction" That is unchecked.  There is nothing else for me to check or uncheck.
In my Image Enhancement section
    "Noise Reduction" is at Driver Automatic settings". 
     "Sharpness" is at Application Settings
     "Other settings" has Film mode detection checked and Adaptive Contrast Enhancement checked
In Image Scaling, nothing is checked.
That's all she wrote.  I wish I saw what you have posted but I just don't.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on January 11, 2014, 04:09:53 pm
Does "Noise Reduction" have a setting like "Off" or "Application Setting"/"Application Controlled"?
If yes, try that.

Also, uncheck "Adaptive Contrast Enhancement"
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 11, 2014, 04:26:30 pm
I can uncheck Adaptive Control Enhancement
Noise reduction does not have an "off" but it does have an "application setting" It also has a "custom setting".  Let me try the first two things first.  Then I guess I can see what custom does if I need to.
 
Doing those things probably has made them look as good as I have seen them look so far.  I don't know if you have any other tricks but if you don't, it's probably good enough for me.  There may be a little left over but if this ends up being it, I can be happy.  Like I said, it's not BR smooth but it is much better then before.  I Really don't know if there is anything else to try.
I just want to really thank you.  Your help was fantastic Hendrik.  
P.S I guess I don't need to mess with the "custom" setting.  Unless there are more tricks in there we can try.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: spiggytopes on January 12, 2014, 12:03:30 am
Just a thought here - my Intel Graphics panel is not in the start menu but bottom right in the system tray area ..... just had a look at it now.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 12, 2014, 12:09:07 pm
Good call on the system tray idea.  It was there and it brought up the same panel I have been working on.  I think I have it as good as it is going to be.  Maybe a quick judder here or ther but It is smooth for the most part so I am satisfied.  Unless there are even more options I don't know about.  Thanks for the help everybody  ;D.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on January 29, 2014, 02:24:18 pm
I really hate to bring this up but it seems like it did not work as well as I had hoped.  A few DVD's that I have ripped looked OK but you can still see more judder then I would like.  Then I played the intro to The Day After Tomorrow.  WOW did that look horrible.  It was not smooth at all.  Almost un-watchable.  But after a few seconds it seemed to settle down and get a little better.  I was hoping for a constant playback viewing experience for all of my DVD's but it seems like that's not the case.  When I am done, I will have about 100 total DVD's ripped and then the rest will be all BR.  Hopefully I can just get over it and enjoy the fact that I have everything at my finger tips.  Oh well  :-[.  It is a let down.   
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: sirkus on January 31, 2014, 02:20:26 pm
I must say that, I'm having serious dropouts with DVDs, too. Blurays are working without problem. I use a resync of -600 ms for video and it's unusable for DVDs.
I have latest versions of all, an i7 with a recent Nvidia card.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: pcstockton on January 31, 2014, 02:42:53 pm
Video is so strange.

A $60 WDTV Live can playback 1080 perfectly, without a hitch.
But a $1000 HTPC cannot.

Why is there not some kind of middle ground?

-Patrick
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: mwillems on January 31, 2014, 02:54:07 pm
I must say that, I'm having serious dropouts with DVDs, too. Blurays are working without problem. I use a resync of -600 ms for video and it's unusable for DVDs.
I have latest versions of all, an i7 with a recent Nvidia card.


I suspect that 600ms resync is the culprit, and that you're experiencing a completely different issue than OP is seeing.  Because JRiver relies on Microsoft DVD Navigator for DVD playback, anything that introduces significant latency will break playback.  See these threads:

http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=79916.0
http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=72534.msg492756#msg492756
http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=84701.0

Blu rays and MKV rips of DVDs should be unaffected by the sync issue.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: mojave on January 31, 2014, 02:55:35 pm
I must say that, I'm having serious dropouts with DVDs, too. Blurays are working without problem. I use a resync of -600 ms for video and it's unusable for DVDs.
I have latest versions of all, an i7 with a recent Nvidia card.

You asked the same thing back in October (http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=84661.0).  ;)

I was going to post links to the answer, but mwillems beat me to it.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: sirkus on January 31, 2014, 03:21:09 pm
Oops :) I didn't rember. Looks like the threads links are the answer to my problem (if it applies to DVD rip in native format (simple copy) that I use).
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on February 01, 2014, 02:46:14 pm
Well, as I said I have given up.  I will keep the regular DVD's I have on there now.  It's probably about 40-50.  Some are better then others.  But I am buying movies that I really like again, or ones that have subtitles again or some that just don't rip at all.  If that's what I have to do to do then so be it.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on March 15, 2014, 06:54:17 am
We recently identified and fixed an issue in Media Center which could have caused the quality of DVD playback (and rips) to be less then desired. If you're still experiencing problems in playback, I recommend updating to 19.0.121 (from the top of the board), and trying again!
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on March 31, 2014, 08:33:59 am
We recently identified and fixed an issue in Media Center which could have caused the quality of DVD playback (and rips) to be less then desired. If you're still experiencing problems in playback, I recommend updating to 19.0.121 (from the top of the board), and trying again!
Thanks.  I will watch a few more regular DVD's to see how bad it still is.  Again, is it hard to upgrade?  I don't want to lose all the settings I already have in MC.  I forget, do I have to pay for the upgrade. 
http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=88373.0
Is that the page?  It looks like they are already up to 19.0.124.  Is that the one I should get? 
Thanks again
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on March 31, 2014, 08:44:16 am
You should not lose any settings, and if you already have any version of MC19, any other updates of MC19 are free.
If you don't have MC19 yet, you can try it for free for 30 days to see if it really improves the quality and might be worth the upgrade!

And yes, the version you linked is the one to get!
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on March 31, 2014, 09:01:14 am
You should not lose any settings, and if you already have any version of MC19, any other updates of MC19 are free.
If you don't have MC19 yet, you can try it for free for 30 days to see if it really improves the quality and might be worth the upgrade!

And yes, the version you linked is the one to get!
OK.  So the price is about $50 right?  And there is a section within JRiver that says "buy"  That's where I go and I assume just follow the instructions.  I don't have MC19 yet.  When I get the time, I will check it out.  I did make the conscious choice though that I only want to put BR on my server for the best quality.  Plus subtitles are much easier to do with BR.  But I may upgrade.  I will download and see what it does for my DVD rips. 
Thanks again.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: Hendrik on March 31, 2014, 09:17:28 am
Since you already own MC18, you can buy an upgrade, which is only $26.98.

Here you can find information about the upgrade process, including a link to the purchase page for the upgrade:
http://wiki.jriver.com/index.php/Upgrade_to_MC19
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on March 31, 2014, 09:43:56 am
Since you already own MC18, you can buy an upgrade, which is only $26.98.

Here you can find information about the upgrade process, including a link to the purchase page for the upgrade:
http://wiki.jriver.com/index.php/Upgrade_to_MC19
Thanks for the link.  I will check that out when I have time to do so.  Glad it's a little cheaper also  :).
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: stewart_pk on March 31, 2014, 08:37:46 pm
I've just about given up trying to play DVD's smoothly and properly through JRiver; yes I'm using the latest version.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: pcstockton on April 01, 2014, 01:15:37 am
I've just about given up trying to play DVD's smoothly and properly through JRiver; yes I'm using the latest version.

rip them (Clone DVD.... worth every penny), then playback.  problem solved.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on April 01, 2014, 06:44:38 am
I've just about given up trying to play DVD's smoothly and properly through JRiver; yes I'm using the latest version.
Trust me.  I know the frustration.  It took a lot of changes that are detailed in this thread to get it somewhere close to where I would like it.  It took settings in my Integra preamp, settings in JRiver and then settings in my video card itself.  I haven't watched a regular DVD rip in a while, but I think I am at a point where it is watchable and much better then it was.  I have also just decided to not put on any more regular DVD's though.  I am just going to re buy the ones I REALLY want on the server and the rest of my DVD's I will just watch through my OPPO.  I am can live with that.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: stewart_pk on April 01, 2014, 09:34:23 pm
Lately I've just been launching XBMC from JRiver in Theater View.
I reckon I might configure JRiver to use this http://mpc-hc.org as an external player for DVD's and see how that goes.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: 6233638 on April 01, 2014, 11:23:34 pm
If you're having difficulty with DVD playback, try this:


Now try playing a video.
Does it play back smoothly, or are you still having problems?


I must say that, I'm having serious dropouts with DVDs, too. Blurays are working without problem. I use a resync of -600 ms for video and it's unusable for DVDs.
If you are using a 600ms correction with DVD playback, you will have to rip them using a tool such as MakeMKV (http://www.makemkv.com/)
This is due to the Microsoft DVD Navigator, rather than anything Media Center has control over.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: stewart_pk on April 02, 2014, 08:10:49 pm
rip them (Clone DVD.... worth every penny), then playback.  problem solved.

Absolutely not, that's when I last noticed the problem when I played a full disc rip.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: stewart_pk on April 04, 2014, 10:22:41 pm
If you're having difficulty with DVD playback, try this:

  • If you have never used Red October HQ before, set Media Center to use it (Tools → Options → Video) and play a video. This should download the required components automatically.
  • Close Media Center and Media Server if it's running.
  • Copy and paste this into the Windows Run prompt (WIN+R) %APPDATA%\J River\Media Center 19\Plugins\madvr
  • Run the restore default settings.bat file in that folder.
  • Download the zip file which is attached to this post, and place the settings.bin file it contains inside that folder.
  • Run Media Center and go to Tools → Options → Video
  • If it is not already, set video mode to "Red October HQ"
  • Enable both "Hardware accelerate video decoding" and "VideoClock"

Now try playing a video.
Does it play back smoothly, or are you still having problems?

Well I don't really know what it did, but this seems to have worked.

Thanks.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: 6233638 on April 05, 2014, 03:38:21 am
Well I don't really know what it did, but this seems to have worked.
Thanks.
It basically cleared the current madVR settings and replaced them with a high performance configuration that should run on just about anything.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: isu1992 on April 12, 2014, 06:06:57 am
I've read just about every one of these posts I can find on choppy video playback.  I have a core i5 3470S chip @ 2.9GHz and 8Gb Memory and any standard dvd that I try to play through JRiver is choppy as all getout.  

I have upgraded drivers...have everything set to application controlled and the hardware accel and video clock on and standard red October checked in settings.  The issue is that it plays just fine in any other application I use except JRiver.  
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: isu1992 on April 12, 2014, 06:35:45 am
Ok so I continue to play with the settings of jriver and finally with Video Mixing Renderer 9 with hardware acel turned off and video clock turned on.  

Both my shuttle HTPC and my intel nuc (which run any other application fine) have issues with jriver now.  I like the interface, but standard dvd playback isn't right.  The only dvds that work fine are the blu rays which make up about 25% of my collection.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: JimH on April 12, 2014, 07:55:11 am
Did you try updating?

19.0.121 (3/8/2014)

6. Fixed: Playback of NTSC DVDs and DVD rips was not smooth on some systems.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: isu1992 on April 14, 2014, 05:05:09 pm
Thanks!  Yep...I have upgraded...still choppy....any other thoughts?
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: JimH on April 14, 2014, 06:15:16 pm
What version are you running now?
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on April 22, 2014, 11:55:01 am
I have been copying most of my stuff since I lost a hard drive but I too still have just a bit of choppy playback but as I said before, I am OK with it since I only have a few DVD's on my server and all the new stuff I am putting on is BR which looks really good.  For ex, I have The Shinning mini series that I ripped using my DVD's.  I am watching that now and it's not that bad.  I will also try a dvd rip again to see how it is just to refresh my memory.  I am just going to leave it as it is right now.  I am not comfortable upgrading and I really don't want to pay anything extra.  As I said, for me it's at a point where I can live with it.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 07, 2014, 11:42:05 am
So if you read this far you know where I am.  Playing DVD rips with just a bit of chop.  But it was always nagging me so here is what followed..,.
If some of you remember, I was having some issues with regular DVD playback on my server.  But I did a number of tweaks and got it looking fairly good with only some chop left.  Well, if there is one thing about me I am persistent.  A while back I tried the media player VLC.  When I watched a DVD rip through that it looked fantastic but I was only getting stereo soundtrack.  Fast forward to this past weekend.  

Going through the audio options on the Baetis(Windows OS) and the VLC player, I am now able to get the multich to come and play as an audio source when I watch a DVD rip through the VLC player.  It really doesn't sound that bad.  Here is what I did.

I had to setup VLC to Directx audio out in two spots and make sure that VLC is "looking" for the 80.3 which is just a simple menu selection Also, one thing that I had to do was to go into the control panel of windows based Baetis server.  In there is an icon named sound.  If I double click on that another widow pops up and I see my 80.3 listed  If you double click on it and then go to supported formats it gives some info.  It says max number of channels is 8.
HDCP supported
Bit depths 16 bit 20 bit and 24 bit.
Then for sample rates it says 32.0 kHz, 44.1kHz, 48kHz and 88.2 Khz
Then in another box it has Encoded formats
DTS audio
Dolby Digital Plus
DTS-HD
Dolby TrueHD
Dolby Digital.
Then in the advanced mode it says Select the sample rate and bit depth to be used when running in share mode.  It goes from 16bit 48000hz(DVD Quality All the way to 24bit 192,000Hz(studio quality).
I have it on the dvd quality.

Now also, I just happen to right click on my 80.3 icon and another screen came up.  It allows me to setup my speaker configuration,  When I did that, I saw that it was in stereo mode.  But, there was a 5.1 surround and 7.1 surround option as well.  So, I put it to the 5.1 setting.
After I did all of that, I played a movie and I got the Multich output.  

According to Craig(a friend of mine on AVS forum), "The "Multi-Channel" on your pre/pro display just means that the server is decoding the Dolby Digital or DTS track instead of bitstreaming it to the pre/pro for the pre/pro to decode.  You must have the output in the VLC player set to PCM.  If the decoder in the server is a decent decoder, and assuming it is working properly, the sound should be virtually the same between DD/DTS decoded in the sever or decoded in the pre/pro.  Your pre/pro will still apply Audyssey EQ and all the BM and Distance settings, so that should be the same also."

Now Craig mentioned the fact that VLC player is probably set for PCM audio and the server itself is doing the decoding but I still get the EQ function and bass management.  He said the only "downside" is that I can't see what format is being played.  I guess he means Dolby Digital or DTS.  To be honest, it really doesn't matter because I only have one or the other on my DVD rips so as long as it plays which ever is on the rip, I am fine with it.  

So that's it.  The server is now doing EVERYTHING I wanted it to do.  I tested just a few parts of some DVD rips and it sounds fine and looks great. If anyone knows if there is a bit stream option in VLC, please let me know and I will switch it.  But if this is as good as it gets, I can easily live it for the 40 or so DVD's I have on the server.  I am so glad I decided to just try one more time and play around.


Movie update:
I just wanted to give a full update(review) now that I have watched a movie.  I watched Open Range last night which is a DVD rip.  First the video was very good.  There was no jaggedness at all.  The colors of the landscape in the beginning were really vibrant.  Detail on close up shots of different people were also very clear and detailed.  I was very happy with the video.  On the audio side I was equally happy.  The thunder at the start of the movie was potent and had some power.  All of the gunshots were crisp and had impact(the shotgun as well).  But the dialog as well was crystal clear.  I could make out every word, even low level dialog and mumbles were clearer now. In addition little insects flying around were    convincing. I will probably watch a few more as tests.

This is probably just for when I watch a movie.  If I wanted to give someone a demo. I doubt I would use a dvd rip.  I would want them to get the full experience so I would use a BR rip.  But for stuff that I watch, it's great.  I am really glad I played around a bit more.  Now everything looks and sounds great :).
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: 6233638 on July 07, 2014, 12:02:56 pm
Mike, is your version of Media Center up to date?
Did you follow my instructions here?

http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=86201.msg606697#msg606697 (http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=86201.msg606697#msg606697)

There is no reason you should have to use an external player like VLC.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 07, 2014, 12:44:46 pm
I am still on MC18 but when I use Red October HQ it looks even worse.  That was with 18.  I guess it's two fold.  I am just not comfortable doing what you wrote and I guess I don't want to pay for MC19.  Maybe my server just can't handle HQ.  I know it can't handle 1080/24.  It looks just awe full when I watch a movie that way.  It may not be ideal, but it works and unless someone can help me actually do it on my machine, I will just stick with I have now.  The DVD watching is only for me and I only have 20-30 DVD movies out of over 200 movies on my server. 
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: 6233638 on July 07, 2014, 01:30:31 pm
The instructions should work with MC18 as well. Just change "19" to "18" - though there have been some changes that improve video playback in 19.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 07, 2014, 01:35:40 pm
So you are saying in this line
 %APPDATA%\J River\Media Center 19\Plugins\madvr
change that to Media Center 18? I also made changes in my video card settings.  Do I have to set them all back to the way they were?
I will think about.  Again, I finally got it working good enough for me so I am kind of cautious on doing anything else. 
But thanks  :).
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: 6233638 on July 07, 2014, 01:37:11 pm
Yes, just change it to Media Center 18
Settings in Media Center won't affect VLC.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 07, 2014, 02:05:03 pm
But back before I used VLC, I think I made all kinds of changes on my video card.  Do I have to go back and undo all those changes.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: 6233638 on July 07, 2014, 02:16:39 pm
Try it and see how things are first. ROHQ should bypass most video card settings.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 07, 2014, 02:18:02 pm
OK, when I am feeling brave ;D, I will give it a shot
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 10, 2014, 08:04:30 am
Mike, is your version of Media Center up to date?
Did you follow my instructions here?

http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=86201.msg606697#msg606697 (http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=86201.msg606697#msg606697)

There is no reason you should have to use an external player like VLC.
I tried to get that file and what I ended up with was something that was a BIN file called settings.bin.  Is that correct?  Is that what the file is supposed to be after it is unzipped?  I don't want to put anything in my system that may screw it up.  I had a hard time getting that file to down load properly.  It kept on downloading as a VLC file since I have that on my machine.  But I was able to convert it back to that other format.  I just want to make sure that is right before I proceed.
Thanks
P.S, I just need the actual file itself, not the folder it is in right?  The folder is named "settings".
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: 6233638 on July 10, 2014, 09:20:01 am
It's bizarre that VLC would try to open a zip file.

Step 5: (http://yabb.jriver.com/interact/index.php?topic=86201.msg606697#msg606697) Download the zip file which is attached to this post, and place the settings.bin file it contains inside that folder.

(that folder being %APPDATA%\J River\Media Center 18\Plugins\madvr )
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 10, 2014, 10:02:08 am
I know, strange right?  But I do have the settings.bin file though.  I just wanted to make absolutely sure it was the right file.  I can't do it at home on the machine itself but I could put the file on a flash drive and do it that way.  It seems to be the simplest way.
Edit, to make things really easy, I just emailed it to myself as an attachment.  Then I can put it on my server easily.
So it seems the two things I have to do is
Run the restore default settings.bat file in the folder %APPDATA%\J River\Media Center 18\Plugins\madvr
Download the zip file which is attached to this post, and place the settings.bin file it contains inside that folder
That folder being located at
%APPDATA%\J River\Media Center 18\Plugins\madvr
Then follow the rest of the steps
Hopefully I can do that :).
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 11, 2014, 06:32:08 am
I give up.  I tried and tried but I just can't get it work.  Whenever I try to get the file onto my Baetis, it converts it to a VCL file.  I downloaded it directly from the thread where it is posted and I even emailed it to myself and both ways did not work.  It still wants open it as a VCL file.  But I was able to get it to open the right way at work, by choosing what program to open it with, at home I can't get it to work.  I just can't get it to open correctly at home.  At work I was able to change the program that opens the file but at home, for some reason, it does not work.  I may try again but I don't know.  As I said, it's only for DVD's and they look good plus they sound fine using the method I am employing now so I may just leave it be.  I don't have any JRiver jedi masters near me to help me out so that's it.  I wanted to thank everyone for their help on this.  At least I can watch my regular DVD rips now without having any video issues.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: 6233638 on July 11, 2014, 11:09:08 am
You should just be able to right-click the zip file and choose Open With → Windows Explorer
You might have to hold down the shift key when you right-click if you are using an older version of Windows.
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 11, 2014, 11:19:59 am
I will give it one more try.  I am using Windows 7.  When I do a right click on my computer now, which is Windows 7, I don't get an "open with" option. 
Title: Re: problems playing standard DVD's
Post by: MikeDuke on July 15, 2014, 12:38:08 pm
Nope.  I can't do that so I give up.  As I said, it's only a few DVD's.  The look and sound are good enough for me for DVD playback.  I am to tired to try it again.