Matt,
I actually covered you on your right on recommendation.
However, I went a "little" further.
I have noticed that when I used a RW CD or DVD and wrote over it several times, it might degrade in performance and give errors.
I found that a "Full erase" fixed the RW problems in many situations.
But if there is data on it, he should be able to read it.
If his RW is good (which I doubt), and he is using a cheapo Dynex RW, then NOT burning at maximum speed probably will work, especially
after hearing that his Fuji works fine.
RWs are a bit more sensitive, and that Full erase from time to time does help.
What fixes that, is to do a FULL erase, instead of a Quick Erase.
That is also way I asked if the Dynex RW as "old" used a lot.
Doing a full erase to a RW that has been busy, can spring it back into life.
If he got a 10 pack or something like that of those Dynex RWs, simply taking a new one out and using it
is the easiest way to go. But, as RWs are more "touchy", I think a slowdown from max speed might be advisable anyway.
Since the Fuji rip worked, I would say that ensures that there isn't a hardware or software issue.
Jon
Same thing with busy SDHC cards, and disk drives.
Also Matt, if you put in a RW, and there is data on it, and try to write with it on MC or others,
it will tell you that it needs to be erased first. Unless you know enough how to do a type of
format that can add to it, but I doubt very much if that is the problem.
To be totally truthful, I don't think it is worth fussing about a single DVD RW with burning. Especially knowing the vendor.