Hi and welcome
So what you are saying is that normally ripping works right?
Well I have to admit, rarely some cds just don't seem to want to rip.
Sometimes cleaning them works. I use dish water liquid.
Sometimes they can be ripped from one optical drive and not another from some bizarre reason. Try another computer?
Sometimes I have needed to use other software. I have this 2009 set and I don't remember having any problems ripping it. But if memory serves the cds in the box set are not Redbook, they are Enhanced CDs. You might try another program just to rip this once ... like EAC or dbpoweramp that have ways to get around non-standard cds. You could also try ripping in non-secure or a burst mode in JRiver (forget what it is called right now). Not really recommended though as you could have errors without knowing it, so it might not be bit-perfect -- so for me that would be a last ditch effort.
Oh just remembered, sometimes your AV or even windows I think can be setup to not allow other programs to load fr'om cds (an enhanced cd might have quik time or some videos on it. Might want to look there too. If the optical drive is not allowing the disk to be read, other software is not going to help
Hope you get this sorted, an absolute must to have this set in any collection !